Archis Mohan And M J Antony

Stories by Archis Mohan And M J Antony

CCI wins a 'competition'

CCI wins a 'competition'

Rediff.com   15 Sep 2010

The court ruled in a judgment running to over 100 pages that the commission can order an investigation into a complaint of an anti-competitive agreement or abuse of dominant position in the market.

Courts hardly use provision to make guilty pay up

Courts hardly use provision to make guilty pay up

Rediff.com   16 Jun 2010

The judges in criminal courts also suffer from tunnel vision and focus on the sentence to be given to the offender. If they are sensitive, they can award compensation to the victim while sentencing the lawbreaker. But it is rarely done, and the Supreme Court has often wondered why.

Three tears for PSUs

Three tears for PSUs

Rediff.com   7 Apr 2010

The SC laments that they spend most of their time in covering their back rather than in achieving their goals.

Courts can help create lung space for cities

Courts can help create lung space for cities

Rediff.com   31 Mar 2010

High courts should replicate for states what the Supreme Court has done for Delhi's environment, says M J Antony.

The problem with vehicle insurance laws

The problem with vehicle insurance laws

Rediff.com   20 Jan 2010

The rate of road accidents in India is so high that the chances of getting run over by a motor vehicle are higher than those of winning a bet at the club.

Debt collection pangs: Borrowers vs creditors

Debt collection pangs: Borrowers vs creditors

Rediff.com   26 Aug 2009

Borrowers can move civil courts to stall recovery proceedings as they have few other choices.

Accident compensation has a multiplier effect

Accident compensation has a multiplier effect

Rediff.com   18 Mar 2009

The accident compensation formula ignores inflation and the rise in life expectancy.

Equal pay for equal work?

Equal pay for equal work?

Rediff.com   26 Nov 2008

The principle of equal pay for equal work, made enforceable so far, that too by a Supreme Court fiat, is all but buried, says M J Antony.

What does 'unfair trade practices' mean?

What does 'unfair trade practices' mean?

Rediff.com   5 Nov 2008

The original MRTP Act did not contain the phrase UTP; it was introduced in 1984 through an amendment. The phrase is open to interpretation yet, though the Supreme Court bench differed on its definition, the issue has not been sent to a larger bench.

Keep language simple: SC on arbitration disputes

Keep language simple: SC on arbitration disputes

Rediff.com   24 Sep 2008

The Supreme Court junks technicalities in international arbitration agreements.

The battle over product designs

The battle over product designs

Rediff.com   25 Jun 2008

With rising consumerism, future feuds will be over the appearance of products.

More power to electricity commission

More power to electricity commission

Rediff.com   27 Mar 2008

It has the discretion to adjudicate disputes by itself or send it to an arbitrator. The use of 'and' posed such a difficulty for the Supreme Court in a recent case and it ruled that 'and' is an equivalent of 'or' in a clause in the Electricity Act and 'or' could mean 'and' in some cases. The judges traversed the English decisions and the Mimamsa principles in Sanskrit texts to harmonise provisions in the Electricity Act and the Arbitration & Conciliation Act.

Top bosses liable for employees' faults?

Top bosses liable for employees' faults?

Rediff.com   12 Mar 2008

Unless the law specifies, top executives are not liable for the fault of their employees.

Kuldip Singh: A name that politicians dread

Kuldip Singh: A name that politicians dread

Rediff.com   19 Feb 2008

Political heavyweights may be still recovering from the tectonic changes brought about by the Delimitation Commission headed by Justice Kuldip Singh after about six years' labour, but to those who have watched this barrister who came from Chandigarh to be elevated almost immediately to the bench of the Supreme Court in 1988, it was not a surprise.

SC toughens stance on bounced cheques

SC toughens stance on bounced cheques

Rediff.com   31 May 2007

The Supreme Court has tightened the rule against the drawers of cheques which are dishonoured for want of sufficient balance in the bank account.

Succour for secured creditors

Succour for secured creditors

Rediff.com   6 Dec 2006

Though there are several laws enabling banks and financial institutions to recover bad loans, the ingenuity of the debtors have always surpassed those of the legislators and the creditors.

The 'full and final payment' trap

The 'full and final payment' trap

Rediff.com   21 Jun 2006

States fight over online lotteries

States fight over online lotteries

Rediff.com   23 Dec 2005

The Centre-states tax conundrum

The Centre-states tax conundrum

Rediff.com   13 Oct 2004